Carithers was jailed in Genesee County without bail and will be in Town of Alabama Court on October 12.
They were taken to the Erie County Holding Center on $250 bail, but Appell was released after posting bail.
The robbery occurred at Clinton Street and Lord Street.
Accident left Dana Papaj, 53, of Grand Island, seriously injured.
Authorities say 19 iPhones and three iWatches were stolen.
According to the woman, Michael O’Neill broke her front door in the process.
Javon Fogan was shot and killed June 15 at 130 Stevens Ave.
Police say two women dressed as nuns attempted to rob a bank in Pennsylvania’s Poconos.
The officer was charged on Tuesday, following investigation that was launched in late May.
The driver was charged with driving without a license and running a red light.
He will reappear in court on Sept. 21.
Authorities say the theft occurred at a store at Maple and Sweet Home roads.
Anyone with information is asked to call or text the Confidential TIPCALL Line at 847-2255.